False Positive Signals For The Economy

By Greg Hunter’s USAWatchdog.com   

According to economist John Williams at Shadow Government Statistics (SGS), we are getting “… false positive signals…” for monthly numbers such as retail sales and unemployment.  So, a recovery looks like it is taking place when a deeper analysis into the government numbers shows it is not.  Williams says in his latest report, “Generally, the economy continues to sink or bottom-bounce; no recovery is in place.”    A perfect example of a false positive is the seasonally-adjusted retail sales data from last year compared to now.  In November 2008, we were in the middle of a financial meltdown.  When you simply compare this November to last November, it looks like there are improving sales.  But if you compare November 2009 to normal years when we were not in a meltdown, such as 2006 and 2007, then retail sales have fallen slightly.  

The government has recently been reporting low inflation numbers and, in fact, inflation has gone down because of the ongoing financial crisis.   But this month, inflation bounced back according to Williams.  The annual Consumer Price Index jumped to 8.8%.  Williams calculates inflation the way the government did it before 1980.  He does that to get a truer read of the “real” inflation picture.  In my mind, this is the real cost of maintaining your standard of “living” as opposed to maintaining the cost of “surviving.”  The cost of surviving is what you get when the government substitutes hamburger for steak when the price of meat goes up.  In short, modern government calculation gimmicks distort inflation to make it look less than it really is.  That can also give a false positive for the economy.

Unemployment is another area that the government distorts to look better that it really is.  Officially, the Bureau of Labor Statistic (BLS) says unemployment is at 10%.  If you calculate unemployment the way BLS did it before 1994, as Williams does, the true unemployment rate would be more than 21%.  If unemployment was reported by the government at more than 20%, it would not look like the country is recovering, would it?

The same distortions are showing up in housing this month according to Shadow Government Statistics.  According to the latest government data, housing starts were up a surprising 8.9%!  In fact, housing starts are about half of what they were in 1990!  The government got the big increase because of calculation gimmicks to make housing look better than it really is according to SGS.  Williams says, “The November housing “gain” is statistically not different from zero.”  In other words, “there is no recovery in place.”  The mainstream media should question all government numbers but, instead, the data is accepted as totally accurate.  It seems to me that government data these days is all about hype and false hope.

Comments
  1. ManAboutDallas

    “Two things only the people desire: bread and circuses.”
    -The Roman satirist Juvenal-

    And 2000 or so years later, nothing has changed. Somewhere, Santayana laughs hysterically.

    • Greg

      Dear ManAboutDallas,
      Great comment! keepem coming!
      Greg

  2. ManAboutDallas

    Do all you can in every way you can to hasten the inevitable final collapse; because, the faster the collapse can be brought about, the sooner it will be over, and the sooner the process of rebuilding a once-great nation can begin.

    Trying to reverse what is now in motion is akin to throwing good money after bad; it simply makes no sense.

    The inevitable can be forestalled only so long. To stand athwart the path of The Inevitable yelling “Stop!” is an exercise in futility, wastes one’s time, and makes one look foolish in the process.

    • Greg

      Dear Mr. Man
      I think you have time to save yourself and that is about it. Thanks!
      Greg

  3. Pat

    I absolutely agree with Mr. Williams. I am a retired Market Analyst. Do a small experiment…take your checkbook from last year and look at the trailing 12 of expenses vs. the twelve months before that. Take the Sunday paper food price specials and go to the library and look up the newspaper fiche from 12 months ago and look at the difference—I call this checkbook inflation…the Govt numbers are absolute lies and have been since 2000…inflation, employment etc…

    The second Real Estate crash is now in action and coming to a neighborhood near you by April 2010..1.1 trillion $ in Option and Alt A ARMS are resetting as I write and major amounts of defaults will hit the streets in April. It is set in concrete. Most of these mortgage contracts [asset values disappear–contracts never do] are underwater and do not qualify for Govt help. Commercial RE is also in for a fall–these failures are TWICE as big as the subprime, and the defaults will go on until EOY 2012.

    What do you think this will do to the banking system which has been raped by the Wall Street Owning Wealthy Elite?

    The consumer is toast–do you really think earnings are going to increase to pre 2007 levels?

    • Greg

      Pat,
      What I hate is the media puts government statistics out in the news and never question their accuracy. This is a journalistic sin of the highest order! Thank you for your indepth comment.

      Greg

Leave A Reply

Please Note: All comments are moderated and manually reviewed for spam. In turn, your comment may take up to 24 hours to be posted. USAWatchdog.com also reserves the right to edit comments for grammar and spelling errors.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *